Epiphany

December 28, 2005 - 12:24pm

Advent was just one of the things they didn’t tell him about at the Baptist seminary. They also never told him about the lectionary, liturgy, Epiphany, Lent, or Ash Wednesday. All the high church stuff. It was too close to Catholicism.

When he first moved to San Antonio he saw a woman with a black smudge on her forehead. He discretely let her know about it.

“You’ve got something on your forehead,” he said softly.

The woman looked surprised. “It’s ashes.”

Foy was confused by her reply. “Ashes, you know, whatever. I was just letting you know that something was on your forehead.”

He learned about liturgical worship at a local Episcopal church where he liked attending evening services and also sitting alone in the sanctuary praying and sometimes dozing off.

That was before his own church had a building, back when he used to study and read at Ben’s office. The Episcopal church was on his way home, and sometimes he would call Jenny and tell her he would be late so he could stop off for prayers. Thursday evenings were nice because Sam would administer the sacrament of unction. On Thursdays there was sometimes twenty people present. They would line up at the altar, and Sam would come by anointing their foreheads with oil that smelled like flowers.

Foy had never seen anything like it. The only healing services he knew about were the embarrassing ones on television, where people threw walkers and canes down the aisles, and the ministers slapped their palms against people’s foreheads. But somehow in the Episcopal church healing seemed right and good. He loved kneeling at the altar. He felt like a regular person and not just a minister. That was the nicest part of it, kneeling there incognito, waiting for Sam to touch his forehead.

There was an special prayer for unction, and Sam said it to each supplicant. You could hear his prayers from down the line. At first a little baritone rumble like distant thunder, then a rolling murmur, then words you could understand; then he was right in front of you. His words seemed powerful because of the repetition. Like chanting. His finger would make the sign of the cross on your forehead, and it was all done for you. It was only for you. Yours.

Later Foy would touch the oily spot on his forehead and smell his finger, breathing deeply the flowers and feeling it make a difference inside his head.

Sometimes he slipped into the sanctuary and was the only one there. He would sit about four rows back and stare at the altar and the cross suspended above it by wires. The quiet was always a surprise. The noises from outside seemed to be coming from another world.

There was another man who sometimes came to pray. He seemed capable of extraordinary concentration and would sit, lost in his prayers for long periods of time. Foy was always looking around to see what everyone else was doing. He didn’t like that about himself.

After seeing each other five or six times, the man came over and introduced himself.

“Hi, my name’s Robert. I’ve been seeing you here a lot lately, so I thought I would come and meet you. You’re not a member of the church, are you? I’ve never seen you on Sunday.”

“No,” said Foy. “I just like stopping by to be alone and pray. It’s so beautiful, you know?”

“Yeah. Well, you’re always welcome here.”

After that they always nodded at each other or said hello.

Sometimes Robert would play the organ, and the music would fill the room so completely that it felt like you had left the earth altogether. Foy loved these times and would close his eyes and let the music be the only thing in the world.

The day came when the polite nods and hellos turned into a small conversation. Foy told Robert that he was the pastor of a local Baptist church. Robert said that he was the music minister and invited Foy to his office near the vestry. There was a keyboard, a table covered with sheet music in neat piles, and nothing silly at all on the shelves. It was a very serious and nice office. “It feels like Robert,” he thought.

On that day the conversation turned in an unexpected and intimate direction. Robert told Foy that he was gay, a thing that surprised Foy greatly. He didn’t know there were Christian churches that would have a homosexual person as a minister. He didn’t know what he thought about that either.

Once Douglas came by the church to see Robert, and Foy happened to be there. They seemed peaceful together and had been partners for a number of years. They were in their 40s.

“Thank Christ I don’t have to make decisions about Robert and his life and the church and all that. I’m nobody here, so it’s not my problem.”

Time passed gently for awhile, slipping along with no bumps or surprises. There was morning and there was evening, day after day. Months passed and Foy became familiar with the Book of Common Prayer and the quiet ways of what he now called his Episcopal church.

About half a year after he met Robert, Foy became aware that Jenny was deeply unhappy and on the verge of leaving him. The awareness of this came like a flash of inspiration. One day he knew nothing of it, and the next day he knew everything. There followed a frantic time where he tried to salvage things with frenetic energy, but it was like scrambling for receipts the day before taxes are due. It’s too late and there is too much. The best you can do is not enough.

His depression was raging but still unnamed in those days. He sunk down to a place where he was numb except for the constant feeling that something very bad was about to happen and the feeling that there was no chance in hell that all this religious stuff was true.

He dragged himself into the sanctuary one afternoon and was glad that no one was there. He sat in his favorite pew and let his head drop down almost to his knees.

“I don’t have to do this, you know? Just say the word. Hell, I don’t even know if you exist. The truth is, I’m pretty sure you don’t exist, but I can’t stop talking to you. You can’t have someone like me being a pastor. You can’t. It’s not right. I mean, the pastor does need to be sure about some things, doesn’t he? There is a bare minimum of belief, don’t you think? Yeah, me too and I don’t have it.”

He tried some of his prayer tricks. He listened close and then let his hearing go all the way out past the church to the freeway where he could faintly hear the trucks going by. It didn’t work. Staring at the cross didn’t work. Breathing deeply and letting the relaxation begin behind his eyes didn’t work. Nothing worked, and his agitation grew.

One of the bad times started happening.

“O God, I have fucked up my life. I’m in the wrong job; I don’t know what’s going to happen with Jenny and the girls; I don’t have any money. I can’t just quit or I would. You can’t possibly want me. You find some way of letting me know that you want me out and I’ll go. I swear I will. I’ll just find a job and be a regular guy if I can figure out how to do that.”

There was the clicking sound of a door behind him and to the left. Foy opened his eyes to find Robert standing by the end of the pew.

He was apologetic. “I’m sorry to interrupt you, but I’ve been meaning to give you something and I keep forgetting, so I wanted to make sure that I didn’t forget the next time I saw you.”

He paused for a second, then continued.

“I was talking with Sam and the other staff about you, and we all agreed that we should give you your own key to the church so that you can come and go whenever you want. We like having you around here; it’s nice. It feels right.”

He held out a little silver key which Foy took with a trembling hand just as he burst into tears. These were racking sobs that made him ashamed so he put his face down and into his hands. Robert put his hand on his back and leaned over a little.

“Hey, are you okay? Well, I guess you’re not, but is there anything I can do?”

Foy looked up with his eyes blurry and his nose running.

“No, I’m sorry. Please don’t worry about me. This just means something…it’s big for me right now. Important. I can’t explain it; it’s too much, but thank you. Tell them It helped me more than they could know.”

Robert looked hesitant to leave, but respectfully withdrew. Foy got up and walked to the back of the church. It was the season of Epiphany and there was a picture of the magi on the literature table beside Sam’s sermon manuscripts. Foy gazed at the picture with intense longing and it seemed like a voice came from the ceiling.

“Even the pagans were called in their own way, to His presence.”

He wiped his nose on his finger and then wiped his finger on his jeans. He looked up to the ceiling and whispered.

“A gay man just gave me a key to his church and said that I was always welcome. A gay man welcoming a Baptist minister to church. Ain’t that some backwards shit? That is hilarious.”

There was the smallest ray of hopeful feelings born of a rogue giggle that popped out the side of his mouth. He looked up to the ceiling again.

“Okay. I understand. I’ll try.”

rlp

Click here to read other Foy Davis stories

Submitted by spidey on December 28, 2005 - 1:42pm.

Good to see Foy again.

Submitted by brotherterry on December 28, 2005 - 1:56pm.

Yes! Yes! Yes!

Foy lives!

Thanks for that! I've traveled a very similar road in the past year with the Lectionary and Gay friends. Good friends. It's a whole new world for this Southern Baptist Pastor!

peace & love,
brotherterry

Submitted by atticus on December 28, 2005 - 2:09pm.

this is good...fiction but with so much of you in it...Foy needs to get away to Colorado or something....i do feel his angst...love the artwork of the angel tucking in the 3...

Submitted by see through faith on December 28, 2005 - 3:02pm.

Yes Yes Yes
As a member of a charismatic UMC congregation, I am drawn to the sacraments the peace and the blessings that flow from the God-filled silence.

Today like Foy I got a gift though this writing. Thank you.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 3:42pm.

Very fine. As an Episcopalian (with a gay music director in our parish), even more touching.

Submitted by Three-Star Dave on December 28, 2005 - 4:00pm.

Hmmm. No need for me to be anonymous. :-)

Submitted by The Token Catholic on December 28, 2005 - 4:50pm.

I love it!

Submitted by WonderSheep on December 28, 2005 - 5:03pm.

Have I ever mentioned how much I LOVE crying at work?

Ah, yes, well, that's because I don't. :P

And yet you manage to do it quite frequently, Preacher-man.
______________________
SWS
Ecclesiastes 7:13

Submitted by wildpoodle on December 28, 2005 - 5:26pm.

I don't know how to say "thank you" enough for these stories, rlp. There is healing for all of us in these gifts of reconciliation.

Thank you for doing the work.

Submitted by jeremyca on December 28, 2005 - 5:28pm.

I like the Foy stories. They always touch me inside. The gay musical director was an interesting spin. Being gay has its "perks!"

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 6:04pm.

This is a wonderful story. Someone pointed me in your direction today and I am so glad she did. Thank you.

Submitted by Jim Sturges on December 28, 2005 - 6:38pm.

Damn.

Gordon, you bring His love into our lives so very intimately and well. Thank you for this ministry and all that it does for me.

Submitted by smcrippin on December 28, 2005 - 9:40pm.

Wow.

Thank you for constantly challenging my assumptions about Baptists.

Submitted by raj on December 28, 2005 - 9:58pm.

Thank you. We are all welcome, I guess...even on the bad days. Let us open our doors ever wider. *contented sigh* Your talent and your ministry here (building bridges, sharing humanity) continue to awe and inspire me. *grin* Thanks, storyteller.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 10:55pm.

Beautiful.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 10:55pm.

Beautiful.

Submitted by Jared Cramer on December 28, 2005 - 11:08pm.

Wow. I'm a Church of Christ (a cappella) seminary student in Abilene, TX who is in the process of being confirmed in the Episcopal church and preparing to seek ordination there. I always say that I've wanted to be a priest (even before I knew it) because I wanted to offer absolution to people--the ministry of reconcilliation. As someone who has been there, weeping in church, at his own screwed up life only to be greeted by costly grace, your story rings true. Thanks.

Submitted by Geodog on December 29, 2005 - 12:17am.

Beautiful and moving, rlp. Feliz Navidad to you, your family and your congregation, virtual and corporeal.

Submitted by IdlePilgrim on December 29, 2005 - 4:13am.

thank you - to be reminded that His grace reaches us even when we question His existance. So often your writings show me the God I believe in yet not the God my church seems to know about.
IdlePilgrim

Submitted by paigeb on December 29, 2005 - 5:23am.

Preacher---it means a great deal to me that you can value my adopted tradition, even when it is so different from your own. It gives me hope that we can all come together in our love for God.

Foy and I share the experience of sneaking into the back, hoping not to be noticed, and finding God on our knees. Thank you

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 8:32am.

"The truth is, I’m pretty sure you don’t exist, but I can’t stop talking to you."

Wow. I feel like that most of the time. There is something so wonderful about seeing your own feelings expressed in "print."

Bad Alice
www.badalice.blogspot.com

Submitted by Josh on December 29, 2005 - 9:12am.

thank you. peace.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 10:52am.

Thank you. God is good.

Submitted by Danny Bradfield on December 29, 2005 - 5:38pm.

Some thoughts that came to me after reading the story:
I'm mostly sure that God exists, but I have trouble talking to God sometimes because I'm pretty sure my IDEA of who God is is way off. But sometimes I can't help myself.
I'm a Disciples of Christ preacher who has said before that, if I weren't a Disciple, I'd probably go for Episcopalian (no offense to Baptists). I've always been a little resistant to high church rituals, yet at the same time attracted to them ... if that makes sense.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 6:13pm.

This made me cry. Things online never make me cry. Well, not in a good way, and this was in a very, very good way. Thank you.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 6:14pm.

I sobbed through half of this, reading it. It's hard to say why, except that you touch something so deep within. I also have those conversations with God, feeling the whole time that I'm a couple of degrees off course, that there's something (a whole lot!) about God that I don't quite get, or I have it a little wrong... but my understanding is close enough to keep me in there talking and interacting and receiving. I think our ideas of God are what's wrong. Our ideas are small and old and are caricatures. One day we'll get more glimpses of the Real Deal, and will realize why it is that we think God probably doesn't exist. I'm guessing it's because our mental constructs of what God is are unreal.

Since I'm probably anonymous again, I'll sign in here:
Wandering Willow
http://blogs.salon.com/0003947

Submitted by bigbrotherinlaw on December 29, 2005 - 6:37pm.

As I read this, my wife became concerned and asked, "Are you laughing or crying?" "Both," I replied. I read it out to her, giving a little explanation of the Foy stories. She loved it, too.

Now, I don't suppose all of our music ministers are gay, but it's common enough for the male ones to be effeminate even if they're straight to bring a laugh of recognition in that detail.

Keep 'em coming, Preach.

Submitted by Sundae on December 29, 2005 - 6:39pm.

All I can say, it's a beautiful story, it moved me to tears.

Submitted by WashLady on December 29, 2005 - 7:19pm.

Good to see Foy again..

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 10:43pm.

Foy--One question:
Did they slip some Welbutrin in that communion cup?
Cyn

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 30, 2005 - 3:03am.

Oh my . . . "Ain’t that some backwards shit?"

God does enjoy Himself sometimes doesn't He? Probably makes up for the lousy hours He has to put in.

Great story . . .

BillB

Submitted by krisinluck on December 30, 2005 - 6:03am.

Foy touches me.

Of course, RLP touches me every time I read, but something about the Foy stories just hit me right exactly where the core of me lives, usually when I need it the most.

I'm in my own struggle of faith (again) with the limitations the church so often puts on God and the way He communicates with us. Last night, I prayed and got an answer in a very similar way as this story. A completely unexpected, out of left field, "you've got to be kidding me" kind of way...and it was exactly what I needed to put my feet firm again.

I wonder if God gets tired of us losing that footing over and over again in our lives?

Thank you, RLP.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 30, 2005 - 8:05am.

This has NOT been one of my top ten Advent/Christmas Seasons. Have been looking for a Christmas Miracle I could claim as my own this year. I have just received it. Thank you RLP.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 30, 2005 - 11:50am.

you said you were going to keep this story for yourself. Still, thanks for sharing.

walter

Submitted by phlipside on December 30, 2005 - 3:02pm.

RLP,
A basketful of thank yous for this essay.

Thank you for treating the Episcopal church with such love and gentleness at a time when we don't seem to be able to do that for ourselves.

Thank you for yet another (!) essay that seems to come just at the moment when I need it. Suffice to say that I understand where Foy is coming from right now and it was a good time for me to read this essay.

New years are times of new beginnings and so I guess I'll pick up my back pack and start again.

Thanks
Jay

Submitted by abiding on December 30, 2005 - 3:06pm.

This is going to be one of my favorites...I can tell. It's beautiful.

Submitted by textjunkie on December 31, 2005 - 12:35am.

RLP, that's a little scary, since this past year we had a pastor join our Episcopal church who had split up from his wife and kids and changed denominations in the process (he wasn't Baptist, but something equally far off--and no, our music director isn't gay, but one of our best priests is)... I think you captured a whole lot, there. I love what you do with these stories! Have a wonderful, blessed 2006!

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 31, 2005 - 2:15am.

reminded me of the novel "Leaving Ruin" by Jeff Berryman. dancewithgod.blogspot

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 31, 2005 - 10:15am.

Thank you for such a wonderful story. It rings with Truth.
The Peace of the Lord be with you.

--Anglican
anglicanjourney.blogspot.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 2, 2006 - 8:41pm.

Reading this and watching the final minutes of Love Actually.......tore my guts up like an opossum in the road.....mushy and all.......................

thank you, RLP

Bishop
bishopsblues.blogspot.com

Submitted by dcypl on January 4, 2006 - 8:10pm.

Thanks for the great Foy stories.
There is a tendency to avoid thinking about many of these situations, but for those of us who have faced them and come out the other side, (whether into bright daylight, or just a slightly brighter reality), realise the importance of fealing the past experiences that have been the bumps on the road so far, but have also been those moments that have shaped and defined who we are now.
Keep em coming.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 6, 2006 - 7:18pm.

thank you so much for this story. it's beautifully written and made me cry as well.

i read your writing in fits and spurts. when i'm not feeling 'the joy down in my heart' i shy away, when i want to read something encouraging i know where to start.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 9, 2006 - 2:13pm.

Yay, Foy!

One more homosexual saves the soul of a Baptist minister. And the rich will be sent away empty.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 10, 2006 - 7:13pm.

I lurk in churches sometimes, you know, when it all gets too much. Sometimes I wonder if God exists, but I talk to him anyway. Sometimes he comes and gives me a key - today it was through you.
Elizabeth

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 10, 2006 - 11:22pm.

...talk about giving legs to everyday miracles--you are epiphany walking...there are so many baptists in the episcopal ranks you would think it constituted some kind of proof of evolution...thanks for a great story that has a ring, if not a whole symphony, of truth--from just another gay baptist musician kneeling in the profound beauty of an episcopal chanted compline.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 16, 2006 - 11:22am.

Hi, I really liked this story...I used to be scared because I saw some bad things about the church--and the Christian Right. Sometimes the church is very hypocritical. But reading your blog lets me know that I'm not the only one who has feelings of doubt. If you ever read any mean or hurtful comments, please ignore them. I think your blog means a lot to a lot of people, including myself, and I hope you always keep writing it.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 18, 2006 - 3:24am.

I don't understand why liberal Christians hold the Bible as important yet reject its clear assertion in both Testaments about homosexuality being wrong. It's easy - just stopping being a Christian. Stop being selfish and cling to your rituals. Join the rest of us in the real world.

Instead, you pretend your doctrine doesn't condemn homosexuality and mock those Christians who point out it does. I find that as intellectually dishonest as Baptist boycotts and Pentacostal faith healings. You all sit on the fence because you want everyone on your side.

Submitted by Mari Mari on January 29, 2006 - 11:34am.

The Bible also teaches that pride, lying, cheating, gossip, and adultery are wrong. So let's kick out the sinners and start a church of one, what do you say?

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 29, 2007 - 8:57am.

people are stranger